Songs › The Beatles › Within You Without You

The Beatles

Within You Without You

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band · 1967 · George Harrison

GLI83

Lennon Leaning

Confidence 78% · evidence quality, not position

The Beatles in a 1965 trade advertisement photograph. — EMI · Public domain

One Beatle, a room of Indian musicians, and a string score written to imitate them.

GARCIAPerformance creates the music

DEAD CENTERNeither wins

LENNONComposition creates the music

100

Within You Without You · 83

Hollow marks: the other 49 scored songs · Hatched band: the Crossover Zone

The case

The strongest honest argument for each side, then the ruling.

The Garcia argument

The basic track was played by musicians from a tradition that does not work from a score, and by one account it went down in a single take. The instrumental passage is a dialogue between instruments of the kind that tradition improvises. No other Beatle is on it.

The Lennon argument

Harrison wrote and directed it, and George Martin scored eight violins and three cellos to follow the bends of the Indian instruments. The tape was then edited and sped up, raising the key a semitone. It was never performed live. The finished piece is a studio assembly of a composed work.

The verdict: GLI 83

Composed and constructed, with a basic track that was played more freely than anything else on its album. It sits below A Day in the Life for that reason.

What is fixed

Melody and lyric
The string score
Tape speed and edit

What is open

The Indian players' phrasing on the basic track

Evidence dimensions

Each runs from 0, Garcia, to 100, Lennon. Their weighted composite is 83. The published GLI is 83, the same.

Structural FixityHow much of sequence, form and duration is settled beforehand?

Elastic

Fixed

A long form in sections with a metre change for the instrumental passage.

Performance ConsistencyHow far can two performances differ and still be the same work?

Transformative

Reproducible

Inferred. There is one realization.

PredeterminationHow much of what matters exists before the performance begins?

Emergent

Predetermined

Harrison directed players from a tradition that works by ear. The strings were scored.

Development MethodHow does the music move forward?

Exploratory

Composed

Part taught and played, part notated.

Recording SpecificityDoes the recording document an occurrence, or define the object?

Documents event

Defines work

Edited and sped up, which changed its key and length.

Transformational tolerance

Low. The piece is bound to those players, that tape speed and that score.

Confidence: 78%

The players went unnamed for decades and accounts of the basic track differ.

Keep arguing

Every placement is relative. These are the songs this one was measured against.

The record

No other Beatle plays on it. Harrison worked with Indian musicians on dilruba, tabla, tambura and swarmandal.Source ↗
George Martin scored eight violins and three cellos to imitate the slides and bends of the dilrubas.Source ↗
Before the vocal was recorded the track was edited and sped up, which cut it to 5:05 and raised the key a semitone.Source ↗
By one session account the basic track was a single take on the first day.Source ↗

Where the sources disagree

Harrison remembered three spliced segments; the session account says one take.
The Indian players went unnamed for decades and personnel lists differ.

Catalog facts

Catalog no.: GLI·TB·013
Artist: The Beatles
Writers: George Harrison
Release: Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967)
Released: 26 May 1967
Duration: 5:05

Sources

Classified 5 October 2026